Most disability policies have a two-year limitation on benefits for disabilities caused by a mental illness or disorder. Thus if the cause of your disability is depression, you will be limited to 24 months of disability benefits. We are now seeing more policies that expands the mental illness limitation to those disability caused or contributed to by a mental illness or disorder. This type of limitation, applied in the extreme, could result in limiting to 2 years the benefits payable on virtually all disabilities. The following case is an example of Reliance Standard Insurance Company’s attempt to expand the application of this limitation.
Our client came to us after having been paid disability benefits for 5 years by Reliance Standard due to a back injury. The doctors were unsuccessful in treating her condition which left her in constant pain. As a result she developed what was diagnosed as a Chronic Pain Syndrome with symptoms of depression and anxiety. This resulted in Reliance Standard terminating her disability benefits claiming that her disability was contributed to by a mental disorder – depression and anxiety.
Stennett & Casino had to file suit and go to trial on behalf of our client on this issue. We were successful in convincing the court that 1) the client’s back pain was the cause of her depression; 2) the disability policy was ambiguous, and; 3) that the mental illness limitation did not apply to mental conditions arising from a physical disability. Our client received a judgement for the payment of all back benefits owed and entitlement to future disability benefits. The court’s opinion can be found at Jarillo v. Reliance Standard Life Insurance Co., 2017 U.S. Dist. Lexis 59928.